Introduction: Welcome to DIY Saturdays, where we roll up our sleeves, embrace creativity, and revel in the world of do-it-yourself projects. Today, I want to share my recent adventure in replacing the heating elements of our AO Smith water heater. Specifically, the A.O. Smith Signature 100 50-Gallons Tall. It’s a story of saving money, learning new skills, and reconnecting with a time-honored tradition of DIY expertise. Join me as we dive into the world of DIY with enthusiasm and optimism.

Water heater elements can require replacement due to wear and tear, corrosion, mineral buildup, overheating, or sediment accumulation. Over time, the heating elements may deteriorate, accumulate mineral deposits, or corrode, leading to reduced heating efficiency. In areas with hard water, mineral scale buildup can insulate the elements, making them less effective at heating water. The frequency of replacement varies depending on factors such as water quality and usage. In regions with hard water, replacement may be needed every 3-4 years, but water softeners can extend the lifespan of elements by reducing mineral content in the water. Regular maintenance, like flushing the tank, can help prolong the heating elements’ life.
Having a water softener can significantly impact element longevity by reducing mineral content, potentially extending their lifespan to 5-6 years or more in areas with softer water. To determine the replacement schedule, it’s crucial to consider local water quality and follow the manufacturer’s guidelines. Regular maintenance practices, like monitoring for sediment buildup and corrosion, can further contribute to the elements’ durability.

Tools Needed: Before you dive into this DIY project, make sure you have the following tools at your disposal:
- A heating element wrench or socket
- A multimeter for checking electrical currents
- A garden hose for draining the water heater
- In case the old elements are stubborn, consider having a pipe wrench or pipe cutter on hand.
The DIY Adventure: Quick Steps to Replace Water Heater Heating Elements
Step 1: Power Off and Water Shut-Down Begin by ensuring safety. Turn off the power to your water heater at the circuit breaker, and shut off the water supply. Locate the cold-water inlet valve, typically situated at the top of the heater. Next, go around your home and turn on all the hot water valves to your sinks and bathtubs until the faucets start spitting, then turn off the valves.
Step 2: Safely Drain the Tank To avoid scalding, let the water in the tank cool down. Attach a garden hose to the drain valve at the tank’s bottom and direct it to an appropriate drainage location. Open the drain valve to release the water. I used a bucket in the house for the first few gallons just to see what type of sentiment we were dealing with; then I took the hose outside. It’s best to drain the tank from the tank instead of trying to drain it through the faucets in your home.
Step 3: Gather Your Tools You’re now ready to dig into the heart of the project. Use your heating element wrench or socket to carefully remove the old heating elements. I found it was easier to remove the elements as the tank was draining – this gave the tank more air flow from the top, but beware, as there may still be some water at the level your elements are located. Carefully move the wires out of the way of any potential water leakage.
Step 4: Inspect and Clean Before installing the new heating elements, take a moment to inspect the access panels and their surroundings for any signs of damage or corrosion. Clean the area as needed and replace any worn-out gaskets.
Step 5: Install the New Heating Elements Carefully insert the new heating elements into the water heater and secure them with the heating element wrench or socket. Reapply the wires and securely screw them in, not too tight.
Step 6: Restore Water Supply and Power Close the drain valve and turn the water supply and cold-water inlet valve back on. Once the tank is filled, restore power at the circuit breaker. MAKE SURE THE TANK IS FULL OF WATER BEFORE YOU TURN ON THE POWER.
Step 7: Check for Leaks After restoring power and water, check for any leaks around the heating elements and access panels. If you discover any leaks, tighten the elements or replace any damaged gaskets. Once that’s taken care of, turn on the hot water faucets in your home until hot water runs to make sure the job is done.
Conclusion: My journey to replace the heating elements in our AO Smith water heater was more than a task; it was a reconnection with the joys of DIY. Not only did I save money and acquire new skills, but I also felt the warm embrace of nostalgia, recalling the days when my dad and I embarked on similar home improvement projects. As I continue this DIY tradition, I look forward to passing on the experience to my own son, sharing the rewards of self-sufficiency, learning, and the satisfaction of a job well done.

Leave a comment